The current state of conversations in regards to Social Media and Business
Okay, look. I don’t mean to step on anyone’s toes here, but how many times do business managers hungry for real Social Media know-how have to suffer through another “Social Media is what’s next” presentation before someone actually decides to help them answer real questions and solve real problems?
Yes. We get it already. Social Media is the future of now. It’s the answer to all of your old-school marketing problems. The holy grail of business growth. It’s all about people and conversations and relationships, don’t you know. Okay, fine. So now let’s get on with it: How the hell does a company actually put Social Media into play?
Before I go on, if your answer includes any of the following words, I may have to reach across the internets and smack you upside the head: FaceBook, Twitter, Blog, YouTube. (No, no, no and no.) Let’s take a giant step backwards here, because if your idea of developing a Social Media program for a company of any size essentially consists of creating a series of embassies on the most popular social platforms on the web, you haven’t just put the cart ahead of the horse, you’ve pretty much squashed it like a bug.
Let me be as clear as I can be about this: Having a Facebook fan page, a twitter account, a YouTube channel and a blog aren’t forward thinking. This is the default position now. The absolute minimum. If you aren’t already here, you’ve already shown that your business is grossly out of touch with the rest of the world (and dare I say, your market?). And by default, so are you. You’ve fallen behind. And if your company does proudly display those little social badges, if indeed you do have a presence on Twitter, FaceBook, YouTube and the blogosphere, congratulations: You’re doing the same thing everyone else is, which is to say that you are merely here.
Having a Social Media presence nowadays is merely the equivalent of what being listed in the yellow pages meant ten years ago. It simply isn’t enough to be there. And if you believe it is, you have seriously underestimated the situation.
Don’t get me wrong: The vast majority of business managers and C-suite executives still need to be shown that Social Media isn’t just a silly fad. That it is a legitimate business discipline worthy of not only investment but special attention. And perhaps most importantly, that by not understanding that Social Media fits in their business toolkit, they will begin to lose increasingly large chunks of market share (among other things) to their smarter, more strategically-minded competitors as early as H1 of 2010. These are realities and facts that still need to be conveyed to decision-makers in the business world. No question.
But the message has already reached a good number of them. So now what? You’ve convinced them to focus on Social Media, but aside from “get on facebook, twitter, youtube and blogs and start engaging,” you haven’t really given them a whole lot to go on. For the benefit of those folks, why don’t we switch gears and meet them where they want us to: In the real and complex world of “how the hell do we actually build this in our own organization?”
Let’s inject a little structure and order into the Social Media for business discussion:
First, let’s get a couple of things straight about the nature of Social Media when it comes to operations (yes, actually “doing” instead of just talking about how great it is):
1. The idea that Social Media professionals are one-size-fits-all needs to disappear. Understand that despite what you may have been told, Social Media practitioners aren’t all community managers and engagement aficionados. Some are data analysts and others are business strategists, while some specialize in operational management, market research, marketing communications or any number of commonly found business functions. Yes, that’s right: Social Media practitioners probably aren’t social media experts at all. They’re simply professionals who use social media because they understand its value to their job and organization.
The topic of incorporating social media know-how into existing organizational roles (rather than creating new layers of superfluous social media expertise to piggy-back on existing functions) is one that we will revisit often in the coming months.
So the lesson here is that if your organization seems to a) suffer from a knowledge gap when it comes to Social Media, and b) filling that gap with dozens, if not hundreds of new employees seems daunting, don’t fret: Focus on training and development first and foremost. Don’t worry about trying to hire a bunch of unemployed marketeers with “social media” roles strategically added to their resumes in the last 18 months. That will get you nowhere fast. There’s a better way. (More on that in a minute.)
2. Effective, sustainable, scalable social media programs all have a basic underlying framework (hinted at by the X-Box Live avatars assembled in the image above.) At its simplest, you are looking at four major building blocks and operational elements:
- Social Media program development (a strategy-heavy function)
- Social Media program integration (almost exclusively an ops piece, especially in the enterprise space)
- Social Media program management (the broadest of the three, basically dealing with the execution of the program itself. Some examples of management functions are listed in the image above.)
- Social Media program measurement (an analytical function which requires little explanation given the amount of time I have already devoted to explaining FRY, ROI, and non-financial impact).
When you start actually building the structure of a Social Media program, especially for a large/enterprise space organization, things get complex fast. But let’s learn how to walk before we start running marathons, okay? Not everyone here is ready to graduate from “isn’t social media just another marketing channel?” so we’ll move slowly out of respect for them.
First things first: Recognizing that in order to build a proper Social Media program within an organization, you must first start with the understanding that these four core elements need to be present in order for things to work properly. Just having a Social Media director and an engagement team won’t cut it. All you’re likely to end up with is a decent management piece with perhaps some light strategy, completely accidental integration thanks to an IT guy or two, and some made-up measurement based on whatever metrics seem to be popular on the Twitternets that week. Sorry but that’s not good enough.
If a half-assed DIY-style Social Media program appeals to you, your boss and your customers, by all means, have fun with that. But if you are the type of manager or business leader with even an ounce of vision, professionalism (and sense of self-preservation), you already know that winging it isn’t really going to produce the results you are expected to deliver.
The alternative is to try and do it right: Actually building an effective and sustainable social media program within your organization by integrating social media (embedding it, even) into every department and business function – and doing so with purpose.
That’s all fine and good, but what if you need help? (No worries. I have you covered.):
So where can you turn for help? Unfortunately, that can sometimes be hard to tell. On the one hand, you have the thousands of self-appointed Social Media “gurus” selling everything from rehashed presentation decks and derivative white papers to stale webinars about essentially nothing. (Thanks for charging me $650 for information I could have gotten for free just by reading Mashable for twenty minutes a week. Great.) And don’t even get me started on the hacks who shamelessly steal my work and that of others and try to pass it off as their own. (We know who you are. You aren’t fooling anybody.)
So how do you tell the good ones from the frauds? Experience. Luck. Savvy. In fairness, you could actually get lucky and find one who knows how to do this (with enough money and enough time, who knows,) but the odds aren’t in your favor.
You could also keep hoping that the operational knowledge you seek will emerge from the various social media conferences you keep attending. And to some extent, yes, over time, you will pick up enough nuggets to become dangerous. No question. But it could take a while. Industry conferences have their value, but real operational training isn’t usually on the menu.
And of course, you could partner with a reputable consulting firm whose team of of experts will guide you every step of the way, from choosing the right measurement tools to the way you should develop engagement strategies. If you ‘re ready for that, have found a partner you know you can work with and have the budget for it, it’s go time. But not everyone is ready or able to go that route quite yet.
A fourth option is to let those of us who know how to do this teach you how without asking you to break the bank or further burden your schedule. We aren’t talking about “boot camps” here. (The idea isn’t to throw as much information at you as we can in a few hours and see how much of it you can retain.) By the same token, you don’t want a training programs to be so light that you walk away from it with solid theoretical knowledge but no practical knowledge. There isn’t a whole lot of value to training if you can’t actually put that training to good use. And to be honest, there’s only so much ground you can cover even with a full day of training. So a group of us put our heads together over the last few months and decided to create something to fill that gap for you and do it right. (Which is to say, do it exceptionally well.) The objective is then to blend training and consulting in a way that makes sense for everyone.
Enter the Red Chair Group:
There will be plenty of time for me to get into what the Red Chair Group is, who will be involved and what types of services we’ll offer in the coming weeks. For now, all I can tell you is that our official launch is scheduled for December of 2009, that our primary objective will be to provide expert level assistance to businesses in need of strategic and operational program management, and that geographically speaking, we will cover a lot of ground. (I haven’t been this excited about a project/venture in a very long time, so it’s pretty hard for me to keep from spilling the beans.)
To that end, one of the first things the Red Chair Group will be launching is a series of executive training programs specifically designed to teach C-suite execs, business managers and agency directors how to develop, integrate, manage and measure social media programs (what we have been talking about in this post). These trainings will be carefully structured day-long events held in major cities around the world. We are currently in talks with partners in 20 key cities to bring Red Chair events to your doorstep.
(I forgot to mention: The whole idea is to bring these training events to you so you don’t have to come to us. This is yet another way we thought we could keep your budget as intact as possible.)
Cities already being added to the 2010 schedule:
- Chicago
- San Francisco
- New York
- Seattle
- Atlanta
- Boston
- Portland
- Philadelphia
- Paris
- Houston
- Sydney
- Hong Kong
- Charlotte
- Orlando
- Toronto
- Brussels
- Tokyo
(If you want us to add your city to the list, let me know. We’ll chat.)
The first Red Chair event will be held in London on December 4th of this year. (Yes, in just a few weeks.) Click here or on the image below to register. For this venue, A+G‘s Scott Gould (of #LikeMinds fame) will be joining me to cover some key topics and learning points. To provide the best possible environment for the event, we’ve secured a space at One Alfred Place, perhaps London’s coolest (and my favorite) business club.
Our schedule for the session on December 4th is pretty heavy, so we plan to promptly begin with introductions at 9:00 am and be well into the program by 9:30. To make things easier for everyone, we’ve set up some group and agency discount packages in case some of you want to buy your tickets together. I strongly encourage that companies with an interest in this level of training (especially enterprise class organizations) consider sending more than one individual.
A note about registration: Though typical Red Chair events are designed for up to 40 attendees, our London launch is limited to only 20 attendees. Since our registration process is first come-first served, you’ll want to register quickly to secure a spot. With our schedule the way it is, it could be a while before we’re back in London.
One last thing: Anyone who registers for Red Chair London will automatically be enrolled in our registration referral program. The way it works is simple: Once you’ve registered, you will be given a special discount code to give friends, colleagues and clients. If they in turn register for the event using your code, they will get 10% off their ticket price and you will get $100 back. Nice, huh? Yeah. We thought you’d like that.
I will let you know as soon as the Red Chair website is up. (We’re building it as we speak.) In the meantime, you can access Red Chair London information via EventBrite by clicking here (or the image below).
I look forward to sharing more about how the Red Chair Group’s plans to help companies of all sizes operationalize social media. I am usually a pretty quiet guy (no, really), but I have to admit that I am having a hard time containing my excitement about this: To know that businesses are finally going to be able to cut through the social media noise and BS in part thanks to Red Chair makes me feel pretty good.
2010 is definitely going to be a fun year.
Cheers.
PS: Let’s give credit where credit is due. Special thanks to Kristi Colvin and Doug Cone for the amazing work they are already doing on the Red Chair Group’s branding and website. You guys are already producing outstanding work.




















Hi Olivier – Good post
Couldn’t agree more that there is far too much focus on the tools (facebook, twitter, blog).
I was at the monitoring social media 09 conference yesterday, in London. One of the takeaways seemed to be that offering listening, monitoring & ‘brand audit’ services is a good way to get through the door of organisations who aren’t socially aware yet. Nothing wrong with that, but I think the problem may be that once they have done a bit of listening and seen that there is relevant conversations going on Twitter or a forum they want to dive in. There is very little work being done in the strategy and operations (from your diagram) boxes. Maybe this is because it takes longer, requires more expertise or because agencies / gurus can make a quicker buck pushing them into a ‘campaign’ mindset? I’m not sure…would love to hear your thoughts.
Red Chair looks like an excellent and timely initiative. The best of luck with it.
Ed
Thanks, Ed. That’s een my conclusion as well. And since I come from a client background (not just marketing but actual management and operations), I noticed that gap as well. Are we going to see you in London, then?
I wish I could! I am actually heading over to Ireland (my homeland) first week in Dec…which is bad timing. I will do my best to get to the next one this side of the pond.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by KrisColvin and Gerald, Thierry de Baillon. Thierry de Baillon said: "What’s next: Operationalizing Social Media." by @thebrandbuilder http://bit.ly/3WnssM [Congratz for launching the Red Chair Group, Olivier] [...]
Excellent post! I always question anyone that can’t talk to how social media can be integrated into the organization and be tied to real business benefits (monetary and otherwise). There are just too many cases of social media being used casually or as another broadcasting channel. If companies want to gain an advantage over their competitors, they are going to have to start looking at social media in a different way.
Look forward to hearing more about Red Chair and possibly attending the Atlanta or Chicago event.
Sweet. I look forward to it.
We’ll start publishing the 2010 dates in a few weeks.
Olivier – great breakdown of what you touched upon last night about the 4 core pieces within an org’s SM structure.
I’m glad you pointed out the unnecessary need for ‘one size fits all’ employees within your team. That’s probably where a big part of integrating SM within your business gets lost, as you have a bunch of SM folks vs. team members who have a diverse understanding of the BUSINESS and how it ties in with social media.
Of course, an experienced SM director/manager/etc. needs to be prevalent within your org, but it’s the scope of how they view SM + business where you understand their worth.
And if I haven’t already via Twitter, congrats on Red Chair, man! Sounds like you’ve got some great, smart things cooking w/that. Looking forward to hearing more about it!
Thanks, Sonny.
Yeah, there’s definitely a need for peeps with a social media focus or specialization, but they’re the exception rather than the rule.
Think of them as the Green Berets of business 2.0: They go into 1.0 areas to teach and advise locals how to operate in a 2.0 world, and essentially help them become expert themselves. They’re there to provide support, guidance and a framework from which to build something they can call their own. I think this is what we’re looking at here.
Olivier,
This is my first time reading information from you. You seem to know your stuff. I’m curious about whether you have considered Denver or Salt Lake City as possible stops on your training tour.
Yes. Denver came up last week as a possibility, actually. If we determine that there is enough demand, we’ll definitely bring an event to Denver (or Salt Lake).
Do you think either would attract 20-40 execs and managers then?
Great post Olivier! I’ve been reading (and watching) a ton of your presentations and blog post these past couple weeks. Your position on social media ROI is so refreshing amongst a sea of “naysayers” who feel that social media ROI cannot be measured. I, like you, believe it can and NEEDS to be measured for numerous reasons.
I really liked your reminder that businesses having a presence on social media is not fwd thinking, but rather the norm.
I also really liked your social media operational structure. Definitely gives me something to chew on and figure out for our business and our clients.
Good. Then my job here is done.
I have no idea. Hopefully you receive more response from people in these areas. I’ll wait for more information and dates from you in the upcoming weeks.
We’re scheduling Tier-One cities first, and keeping our eyes and ears open for Tier-Two and -Three as well. So it’s just a matter of time before we hit every city.
Once the site is up, I’ll update you (and everyone) every time we add a city to the world tour.
We also have plans for other trainings, so this thing is only going to keep growing.
Anyone suggested Detroit or any MI venues yet? Great ideas!!
Yep. I’m not sure when we’ll get to Detroit, but I would LOVE to do a Red Chair event there. (Or anywhere in Michigan, for that matter.)
We’ll put one together wherever and whenever it is most needed by the local business community. You guys tell me where you think we can fill up a room with execs and managers, and we’ll add you to the schedule.
I’m really excited for you and Scott and all the folks who will get to attend these trainings, Olivier. I didn’t think this would happen until sometime in 2010, so to see you launching this venture ahead of the new year is so awesome and I know how hard you’ve been working on it.
I can’t wait to attend, myself. I have learned so much from you that has impacted the work I do for clients and the things I suggest – I can’t wait to learn more! Best of luck with the first Red Chair trainings and at the next Like Minds!
Thanks. And I have to say again, thanks for the work you’re doing on the design and branding. Stellar.
And yeah, if you think that the blog is helpful and insightful, wait until you sit through a Red Chair training.
There’s a reason the first presentation I ever published to Slideshare hit 50,000 views in just a few short months.
Not only do I know this stuff, I really love teaching companies how to kick ass.
See you at a Red Chair training very soon.
Hi Oliver
Great post. I work with large corporates here in Sydney and the volume of proposals I see from trad agencies and so called social media agencies which have “the twitter” “the facebook” and sadly even one with “the digg” is appalling.
Look forward to hearing your plans for coming to Sydney and welcoming you here!
Fi
Awesome. Yeah, the “digital ghost-town manufacturers” are out selling Facebook and Twitter en force these days. I just presented to a roundtable of agency execs in California last week and covered that very topic. We really need to put a stop to that horrible practice. Ad agencies need to take this seriously if they’re going to enjoy any success in this space. The peeps I was speaking with were very receptive to that, which is encouraging.
I will definitely let you know when Red Chair Sydney is ready to roll.
Cheers.
All I can say is how refreshing to read this articulate post about social media management and the need to focus on training and development across the enterprise. And I wish you tons of luck with Red Chair. We are currently focused on skill development training and executive briefings, also coming from enterprise experience and focus. While I guess I could consider you a competitor, you are so right on I can’t help but hope you are widely successful. More operational integration knowledge is essential!
Well Linda, the good thing is that so few of us a) know how to do this and b) are doing it that we’re not really competitors, are we? Plenty of businesses to go around. And as you well know, you and I can only cover so much ground on our own. There comes a point when being part of a network really pays off (for the clients and for us). I’ll definitely think of you next time I need more brains and hands on a project.
Lots of opportunities to collaborate on building something real and valuable, especially in the next few years.
Thanks a bunch for the kind words. Talk to you soon.
Bravo! Glad to see you putting some “feet” on this, Olivier! This is exactly the right approach to start moving the ball downfield – the hype cycle needs to be over, and it’s time to get some concrete stuff in the mix. Love it.
Thanks, Steve. I just wish I’d been smart enough to figure out how to do this a year ago.
So much time wasted, so many companies already on the wrong path having to stop and retool…
I should have done this a lot sooner.
Good article.
I hold two of the four roles now, strategy and program management.
It was not clear from what you described if your course would be of value to me or it is focused on upper management who really don’t have as good a grasp on these topics as they might.
I’m in the San Francisco area, should I wait for your announcement which will have more details or can you provide more information on the content now?
Thank you.
Great question. The first round of trainings are geared towards upper management AND professionals in your position.
For upper management, its a matter of seeing the big picture. The framework. How it all fits together and how to make it work.
For peeps in your position, the value is to a) go over best practices (there are always areas to tweak and improve on) and b) further your understanding of the areas you aren’t responsible for.
The second round of trainings (due to launch in H2 of 2010) will be geared towards the four specific disciplines. Instead of spending 2 hours on each of the four areas, these will be 8 hour trainings focusing on just one: Strategy and program build, Operations and Integration, Program Management, and finally measurement. There’s a good chance that the Program Management track might be further split into different sub-categories: Community Management, Online Reputation Management, Market Intelligence, etc.
The website should be up soon, and the trainings will start being listed there as soon as they are scheduled. San Francisco is one of the cities we want to hit in 2010, so you probably won’t have to wait too long.
Cheers.
Back at you, Olivier. I couldn’t have your back more on this!! We’ve moved into a new era from “the practice” of social media to “managing socially.” Looking forward to the discussion with you and others of the evolution of social media management/education within the enterprise and hopefully evolving some clarity on the skills people and enterprises need to develop. Been doing a lot of thinking and “tinkering” in this arena for a several years. Organizations need to be taking the responsibility for their social media activities (read “socially-oriented enterprises”), but lack the proper perspective and skills. =
The more *quality* professional education the better for everyone. And it is simply time to help professionals get the skills they need to help their organizations become modern companies.
BTW, I meant “competitor” in the classic sense – in yesteryears terms – not in my operational sense. Otherwise I wouldn’t be so excited about your initiative!! Also, your love the articulate rant about conferences. Glad to know I wasn’t just being “anti-social” when I made the decision to stop attending or recommending.
It is time to deliver value to those struggling to get clarity.
I’m printing this and posting it to my wall of wisdom. (Yes, there is such a thing.)
Hi Olivier thanks for sharing the insight, I think Still more then 85% of the conversations are not completed without the name of these popular sites no matter what these conversations are.
This mindset has to be changed as now people should think much deeper into the scenario.
The 4 core steps outlined by you can easily form the base of a good business strategy in which social media plays just a role and its not the whole thing.
The reason why these 4 areas would become bigger and bigger is that the information floating in social media is increasing at quite a velocity, for example recently I got through a post on David Berkowitz’s blog where he had mentioned 100 ways of measuring social media, so you have to have a team specifically doing this and the same goes for other areas as well.
Thanks Again !!!
And yes is it a possibility that you can come down to New Delhi, India for the Red Chair training event.
Well… Look at David’s list as a very large menu from which to pick what makes the most sense. You don’t want to actually measure 100 things. That’s just silly and unrealistic for most companies.
Measure what matters. Build what you need to build. It all needs to be very specific to what matters to your organization.